Expert opinion on the effect of blinding light ...


These publications by acknowledged experts explain in medical terms why blinding light is damaging to the human eye.

In mandating these blinding lights, the European Commission and their traffic focussed advisers have neglected to consider the ophthalmological and neurological effects of blinding other drivers with High Intensity Discharge (HID) Xenon headlamps and High Power laser like LED DRL both of which emit light close to the eye damaging 370nm UV end of the light spectrum.


To justify their studies EU traffic "experts" used slides in a laboratory which cannot emulate the photon emissions beamed directly into a driver's eye.
The EU then commissioned meta-analysis (studies of studies) which compounded their errors to produced the desired result.


Only the Japanese Government have carried out real world tests and they determined that 200cd was an appropriate intensity.


The EU have mandated 400 - 1,200cd DRL from February 2011 in a futile attempt to compete with the power of the sun!!
In analogy to the Hippocratic Oath some particularly conscious scientists are swearing a voluntary oath:
"I promise to work for a better world, where science and technology are used in socially responsible ways. I will not use my education for any purpose intended to harm human beings or the environment. Throughout my career I will consider the ethical implications of my work before I take action. While the demands placed upon me may be great, I sign this declaration because I recognize that individual responsibility is the first step on the path to peace." Heather Stewart

"I will be honest and I will not do anything which in my view is to the obvious detriment of the human race. Second, if later I find that my work is being used in my view to the detriment of the human race I will endeavour to nullify these developments." Peter Reineker


DRL and Xenon-HID lights imply a Violation of Protection, offending against the Equality Principle and violates Article 3 of the
 Universal Declaration of Human Rights 
"Everyone has the right to life, liberty and personal security "

 

Daytime Running Light Studies - please see
http://www.dadrl.org.uk/DRLstudies.html
http://www.lightsout.org/studies.html

 

Daytime Running Lights: Effect on Vulnerable Road Users                                          Prof Peter Heilig University of Vienna 

Human and Environmental Effects of Light Emitting Diode (LED) Community Lighting American Medical Association - Louis J Kraus MD June 2016
Also see associated CNN article "Doctors issue warning about LED streetlights"

Quotes for AMA report Page 3  Unshielded LED Lighting (also on vehicles)

Unshielded LED lighting causes significant discomfort from glare. A French government report published in 2013 stated that due to the point source nature of LED lighting, the luminance level of unshielded LED lighting is sufficiently high to cause visual discomfort regardless of the position, as long as it is in the field of vision. As the emission surfaces of LEDs are highly concentrated point sources, the luminance of each individual source easily exceeds the level of visual discomfort, in some cases by a factor of 1000.1
Discomfort and disability glare can decrease visual acuity, decreasing safety and creating a road hazard.

Page 5 Recommendations

3. That our AMA encourage the use of 3000K or lower lighting for outdoor installations such as roadways. All LED lighting should be properly shielded to minimize glare and detrimental human and environmental effects, and consideration should be given to utilize the ability of  LED lighting to be dimmed for off-peak time periods. (New HOD Policy)  

Human Responses to Lighting based on LED  Public Health England, Chartered Institute of Building Services and Society of Light and Lighting May 2016

5.2 Blue Light hazards and hotspots, page 18

"Some wavelengths are more effective at causing harm than others, with the peak effect very close to the sensitivity of the short wavelength cones, in other words blue light at around 440 nm. The blue LEDs used in street, office and domestic LED lighting generally emit at around 450 nm to 460 nm. For this reason, there are concerns that the guidelines may be exceeded, especially by lights with hotspots arising from LED chips in direct view."

Blinding Headlights and LED Lights: Dangerous on Roadways and Off
by Suzanne Coleman MD 

Light pollution: the possible consequences of excessive illumination on retina Eye 30, 255-263 (February 2016) | doi:10.1038/eye.2015.221 M A Contín, M M Benedetto, M L Quinteros-Quintana and M E Guido     Abstract:

Light is the visible part of the electromagnetic radiation within a range of 380–780 nm; (400–700 on primates retina). In vertebrates, the retina is adapted to capturing light photons and transmitting this information to other structures in the central nervous system. In mammals, light acts directly on the retina to fulfill two important roles: (1) the visual function through rod and cone photoreceptor cells and (2) non-image forming tasks, such as the synchronization of circadian rhythms to a 24 h solar cycle, pineal melatonin suppression and pupil light reflexes. However, the excess of illumination may cause retinal degeneration or accelerate genetic retinal diseases. In the last century human society has increased its exposure to artificial illumination, producing changes in the Light/Dark cycle, as well as in light wavelengths and intensities.

Light in man's environment. Marshall J. Eye (Lond). 2016. Abstract:

Light in the form of solar radiation influenced early civilisations and resulted in the independent development of a number of sun-worshipping dieties. These were of particular importance as hunter gatherers transformed into settled agricultural societies. All artificial light sources were synonymous with fire, and early civilisations began to expand their visual day by burning brands, oil, and candles. Fire-based light sources extended for thousands of years and were still present in the era of gas lighting. Light meant fire risk. The advent of incandescent bulbs and the era of electric lighting really only expanded in the early part of the twentieth century. Fluorescent lighting became available in the 1940s, and today the drive for low energy has resulted in a plethora of novel light sources-in particular, light-emitting diodes (LEDs). Evolution governed the development of the eye in relation to roughly 12 h of light gradually changing to 12 h of darkness. Today almost daylight levels can be achieved abruptly at the flick of a switch.

Eyecare research LED cause 5x more phototoxicity Dr. Celia Sanchez-Ramos RCC Harvard

lnattentional Blindness and Conspicuity    Professor Marc Green Phd Yale University updated 2011

Tailored to the Eye P. Heilig March 2015 Professor Peter Heilig University of Vienna explains how bright light affect the eye down to photon and molecular level

Daytime Running Lights - What good?  P. Heilig Jan 2014 "Traffic Safety: No Benefit, Contravention of Human Rights, Children at risk particularly on pedestrian crossings

Bright white headlights: are they safe?  Flyingshingle.com Jan 2012
Michael D. Mehta, Ph.D. Dean and Professor, Faculty of Arts Thompson Rivers University BC

Light Pollution P. Heilig December 2011 "Light Pollution can be prevented. It has to be prevented – for the sake and for the benefit of ecology, economy and sensory physiology. And the beauty and the magnificence of the world heritage Starry Sky".

Verirrte Lichtstrahlen (Stray Light Rays) P. Heilig June 2011 - deutch

Letter to Lightmare 12 May 2011 by Professor David Rees Ph.D. FIoD, FRAS

Dr. Daniel McQueen:

"Although I am a cyclist, I have more problems with HID lights when driving my car, maybe because when cycling, I am higher than when driving. As a motorist I am frequently completely blinded by Sports Utility Vehicles driving behind me, they are so high, and the glare in my wing mirrors, actually blinds me to the road ahead, I dip the rear view mirror, but can do nothing about the wing mirrors. I had assumed that it was ignorant motorists driving with undimmed lights, I now realise that the lights are dipped, they are just too bright to be safe for other road users".
 

Dr. Trevor Dale B.Sc., Ph.D., LL.B

"Headlights do not help much in well lit streets and my night vision is destroyed each time a vehicle passes with headlights on. Sidelights are quite sufficient in these cases. Headlights should be reserved for emergency use and for the dark. They also draw indirectly on fuel to power them – not green." 
 

Dr. Richard H. Barton

"These high intensity lights have a bluer spectrum than the older lights, which adds to refractive scatter, and in fact because of this spectral balance, is also less useful for yielding information from the reflected light" 
Dr. Richard H. Barton.

Glare on the roads: Are we being driven to distraction?
Geoff Roberson from the Association of Optometrists says that HID-Xenon lights could be a problem for motorists - April 2011

How Much Light do we need?  P.Heilig Nov 2010 - deutsch 
Prof. Peter Heilig lucidly explains how vehicle lights affects the safety of children, adults, the elderly and athletes

Safe Cycling P. Heilig Apr 2010 - english 
Safe Cycling P. Heilig Apr 2010 - deutsch
Safe Cycling is a good introduction to the problems blinding Xenon-HID and DRL lights cause vulnerable road users.

Impaired Perception - Driving and Sports P. Heilig Aug 2010 - english
Impaired Perception - Driving and Sports P. Heilig Aug 2010 - deutch

Impaired Perception takes a step further explaining how blinding Xenon-HID and DRL lights cause change blindness, inattentional blindness, effect on Visual Short Term Memory and Capacitive Dysfunction

Why HID Xenon headlights bother older drivers   British Journal of Ophthalmology 2003
M A Mainster, G T Timberlake, Department of Ophthalmology, University of Kansas Medical Center,

"Governmental regulations determine which headlights we encounter. Acceptance or rejection of the current generation of HID xenon headlights ultimately depends on their record in traffic and litigation.

Can Xenon lights affect vision?
Dr. Edgar Leuenberger, Asian Eye Institute  March 2009

Retinal Light Damage 2009 Dr. P. Heilig, Dr. Elena Rozanova, Dr. Jasminka Godnic-Cvar

EPIGUS - Prof. Dr. Ernst Pfleger Sep 2007  deutch  Report on the failed Austrian DRL experiment

Monitor on Psychology - inattentional blindness - Siri Carpenter

The Morbid Philosophy of Advertising Dr. P. Heilig Oct 2010 english
Unrestrained Advertising Dr. P.Heilig Oct 2010 - deutsch

These publications describe how the cumulative effect of roadside adverts diminish safety

Disability and Discomfort Glare of Headlamps - english  Locher, J.&  Kley, F. (2009). ISAL 8th International Symposium on Automotive Lighting (38 - 42)

This paper seeks to justify Xenon headlights - it concludes in static laboratory conditions that there is minimal difference between Xenon-HID, LED and normal Tungsten-Halogen headlights if correctly aligned.  However if mis-aligned discomfort glare is present.
A major failing of this static laboratory experiment is not carrying out real-world tests on moving vehicles with Xenon-HID headlamps - when they traverse legal speed humps or potholes they temporarily blind drivers.
This is a real concern as the laboratory was Hella's who make headlights for many vehicles.

Glare from oncoming traffic: Headlight properties -Visual performance and glare – deutsch
Locher, J., Schmidt, S., Isenbort, A., Kley, F.&  Stahl, F. (2008)

Blendung durch Gegenverkehr: Der Einfluss unterschiedlicher Scheinwerfereigenschaften af die Sehleistung und das subjektiv empfundene Blendgefühl. Zeitschrift für Verkehrssicherheit, 54 (1), 10 – 15.

Countermeasures for the effects of reducing Headlight Glare

AAA Foundation 2001  Mace, Garvey, Porter, Schwab, Adrian
This report proposes using the well known effects of polarised light to minimise headlight glare and seems an eminently sensible solution

Inattentional Blindness by Marc Green Ph. D.
Occupational Health & Safety Canada 2002 

  Professor W.Schober

BBC April 2011
Sangita Myska
The Lightmare



The Cabbies Guide to Motor Manners


Also see
Media


@lightmare3